AIGC Research User Study

Guidance Before You Start - IMPORTANT
  1. In this survey, you're given a series of four sets of images along with a reference image. Your goal is to choose the best one of these sets that excels in three criteria: "Reference Subject Similarity", "Prompt Alignment", "Image Quality". Write down your choice of the best set in the questions' text boxes as A/B/C/D, where Set A = 1st row, Set B = 2nd row, Set C = 3rd row, Set D = 4th row.
Explanation of the criteria:
  1. Reference Subject Similarity: Measures how consistently the reference subject's appearance is maintained across all images in the set, ensuring the same subject is depicted.
  2. Prompt Alignment: Evaluates how closely each image aligns with its corresponding text description.
  3. Image Quality: Assesses the aesthetic quality of the images.
  4. To quicken your selection process, you should process through each criteria one-by-one, starting from "Reference Subject Similarity", then "Prompt Alignment", and finally "Image Quality". For example, if you think a set has much poorer "Reference Subject Similarity" than the majority of other sets, you can eliminate this set immediately; secondly, if you think a set has much poorer "Prompt Alignment" than the majority of other sets, you can eliminate this set immediately; finally, if you think a set has much poorer "Image Quality" than the majority of other sets, you can eliminate this set immediately.
Example
The first image is the reference image with the text description:
  1. "A photo of a teenage girl with a backpack"
The reference image is followed by four image sets (A, B, C, D), each in a row. Each column corresponds to the same text description:
  1. "riding a bicycle through suburban streets"
  2. "sitting under a tree reading a novel"
  3. "taking photos with a vintage camera"
  4. "working part-time at a local bookstore"

In this example, set A should be chosen.

Explanation:
Note: The asterisk(*) denotes where you can immediately eliminate the set.

Set A is the best in "Reference Subject Similarity", "Prompt Alignment" and "Image Quality".
Set B is not chosen because despite it has good "Reference Subject Similarity", it's lacking in "Prompt Alignment"* (and also in "Image Quality", as it's not as natural and realistic-looking as Set A).
Set C is not chosen because despite it has good "Reference Subject Similarity" and "Prompt Alignment", it's lacking in "Image Quality"*, as it's not as natural and realistic-looking as Set A.
Set D is not chosen because it's lacking in "Reference Subject Similarity"* (and also in "Image Quality", as it's not as natural and realistic-looking as Set A).
1.Enter the best set based on the three criteria
The first image is the reference image with the text description:
  1. "a photo of a middle-aged woman with brown curly hair"
The reference image is followed by four image sets (A, B, C, D), each in a row. Each column corresponds to the same text description:
  1. "jogging in the morning through city streets"
  2. "painting on an easel in her art studio"
  3. "reading to children at bedtime"
  4. "practicing yoga in a sunny room"
2.Enter the best set based on the three criteria

The first image is the reference image with the text description:
  1. "a photo of a white table lamp"
The reference image is followed by four image sets (A, B, C, D), each in a row. Each column corresponds to the same text description:

  1. "placed on a desk beside books"
  2. "sitting by a window on small table"
  3. "placed in a cozy reading corner"
  4. "sitting on a wooden nightstand"

3.Enter the best set based on the three criteria

The first image is the reference image with the text description:
  1. "a teenage girl, bright eyes, pink hoodie "
The reference image is followed by four image sets (A, B, C, D), each in a row. Each column corresponds to the same text description:
  1. "standing in a bookstore"
  2. "walking on sidewalk"
  3. "sitting under a tree reading"
  4. "running slowly on a track"
4.Enter the best set based on the three criteria

The first image is the reference image with the text description:
  1. "a photo of an elderly man in a black t-shirt"
The reference image is followed by four image sets (A, B, C, D), each in a row. Each column corresponds to the same text description:

  1. "sitting in a library reading a newspaper"
  2. "working in a garden tending to flowers"
  3. "playing chess in a park"
  4. "feeding birds by a peaceful pond"

5.Enter the best set based on the three criteria

The first image is the reference image with the text description:
  1. "a girl, yellow t-shirt, with her golden retriever puppy"
The reference image is followed by four image sets (A, B, C, D), each in a row. Each column corresponds to the same text description:
  1. "playing in a sunny backyard"
  2. "walking down a street"
  3. "sitting on a park bench"
  4. "standing in a flower garden"

6.Enter the best set based on the three criteria

The first image is the reference image with the text description:
  1. "a man, white t-shirt, with his tabby cat"
The reference image is followed by four image sets (A, B, C, D), each in a row. Each column corresponds to the same text description:
  1. "relaxing in a cozy living room"
  2. "working in a home office"
  3. "by a fireplace on winter evening"
  4. "in a sunroom with plants"
7.Enter the best set based on the three criteria

The first image is the reference image with the text description:
  1. "an elderly man with glasses, with his pet parrot"
The reference image is followed by four image sets (A, B, C, D), each in a row. Each column corresponds to the same text description:
  1. "sitting in a quiet study room"
  2. "standing in a greenhouse"
  3. "sitting on a garden bench"
  4. "in a conservatory”

8.Enter the best set based on the three criteria

The first image is the reference image with the text description:
  1. "a photo of a comfortable leather armchair"
The reference image is followed by four image sets (A, B, C, D), each in a row. Each column corresponds to the same text description:
  1. "placed near a large window with curtains"
  2. "sitting in a reading nook with bookshelves"
  3. "accompanied by a small side table"
  4. "positioned in a sunroom with plants"

9.Enter the best set based on the three criteria

The first image is the reference image with the text description:
  1. "a boy with short black hair, with his golden hamster"
The reference image is followed by four image sets (A, B, C, D), each in a row. Each column corresponds to the same text description:

  1. "doing homework at his desk"
  2. "sitting on his bed"
  3. "having breakfast in the kitchen"
  4. "sitting under a tree in park"
10.Enter the best set based on the three criteria

The first image is the reference image with the text description:

  1. "A photo of a woman, blue t-shirt"
The reference image is followed by four image sets (A, B, C, D), each in a row. Each column corresponds to the same text description:
  1. "sitting at a cafe table reading a book"
  2. "standing in a grocery store"
  3. "sitting on a park bench"
  4. "standing at a bus stop"
11.Enter the best set based on the three criteria

The first image is the reference image with the text description:

  1. "a middle-aged woman, friendly smile, red sweater "
The reference image is followed by four image sets (A, B, C, D), each in a row. Each column corresponds to the same text description:
  1. "jogging along a river path"
  2. "standing in a grocery store aisle"
  3. "walking through a library"
  4. "sitting at a cafe table"

12.Enter the best set based on the three criteria

The first image is the reference image with the text description:
  1. "A photo of a teenager, gray hoodie "
The reference image is followed by four image sets (A, B, C, D), each in a row. Each column corresponds to the same text description:
  1. "running to catch up with friends"
  2. "sitting in the back of a classroom"
  3. "standing outside a convenience store"
  4. "sitting on steps texting on phone"

13.Enter the best set based on the three criteria

The first image is the reference image with the text description:
  1. "A photo of a cute kitten"
The reference image is followed by four image sets (A, B, C, D), each in a row. Each column corresponds to the same text description:
  1. "playing in the grass"
  2. "lying on a desk, bathed in soft morning light"
  3. "hiding under a chair"
  4. "sitting in a wicker basket"

14.Enter the best set based on the three criteria

The first image is the reference image with the text description:
  1. "A photo of a golden retriever puppy"
The reference image is followed by four image sets (A, B, C, D), each in a row. Each column corresponds to the same text description:
  1. "running on the beach"
  2. "playing with a ball in the yard"
  3. "sitting by a fireplace"
  4. "standing in tall grass"

15.Enter the best set based on the three criteria

The first image is the reference image with the text description:
  1. "A photo of a white fluffy rabbit"
The reference image is followed by four image sets (A, B, C, D), each in a row. Each column corresponds to the same text description:

  1. "hiding under a tree"
  2. "sitting on green grass"
  3. "resting in a flower garden"
  4. "lying in soft hay"

16.Enter the best set based on the three criteria

The first image is the reference image with the text description:
  1. "a girl with long brown hair, with her small white cat"
The reference image is followed by four image sets (A, B, C, D), each in a row. Each column corresponds to the same text description:
  1. "sitting in a sunny school classroom"
  2. "having lunch on school rooftop"
  3. "sitting on a park bench"
  4. "reading in a cafe by the window"

17.Enter the best set based on the three criteria

The first image is the reference image with the text description:
  1. "A photo of a baby panda"
The reference image is followed by four image sets (A, B, C, D), each in a row. Each column corresponds to the same text description:

  1. "climbing a bamboo tree"
  2. "rolling on the ground playfully"
  3. "sitting by a peaceful pond"
  4. "sleeping against a rock"
18.Enter the best set based on the three criteria

The first image is the reference image with the text description:

  1. "A photo of a baby elephant"
The reference image is followed by four image sets (A, B, C, D), each in a row. Each column corresponds to the same text description:
  1. "walking in the savanna"
  2. "standing under a big tree"
  3. "playing in mud puddles"
  4. "running through tall grass"


19.Enter the best set based on the three criteria

The first image is the reference image with the text description:

  1. "A photo of a wise owl"
The reference image is followed by four image sets (A, B, C, D), each in a row. Each column corresponds to the same text description:
  1. "sitting in a cozy library"
  2. "resting in an old barn"
  3. "perched on weathered wood"
  4. "resting on stone wall"
20.Enter the best set based on the three criteria

The first image is the reference image with the text description:
  1. "A photo of a fluffy squirrel"
The reference image is followed by four image sets (A, B, C, D), each in a row. Each column corresponds to the same text description:
  1. "collecting nuts in autumn"
  2. "sitting on a park bench"
  3. "standing on a bird feeder"
  4. "resting on a tree stump"

21.Enter the best set based on the three criteria

The first image is the reference image with the text description:
  1. "A photo of a small hedgehog"
The reference image is followed by four image sets (A, B, C, D), each in a row. Each column corresponds to the same text description:
  1. "drinking from a small stream"
  2. "walking through fallen leaves"
  3. "resting by a garden path"
  4. "lying on soft moss"

22.Enter the best set based on the three criteria

The first image is the reference image with the text description:

  1. "A photo of a teenager, gray hoodie"
The reference image is followed by four image sets (A, B, C, D), each in a row. Each column corresponds to the same text description:
  1. "sitting at a computer playing games"
  2. "standing at a skate park"
  3. "walking home from school"
  4. "walking through a suburban neighborhood"

23.Enter the best set based on the three criteria

The first image is the reference image with the text description:

  1. "A photo of a man, white t-shirt"
The reference image is followed by four image sets (A, B, C, D), each in a row. Each column corresponds to the same text description:
  1. "sitting at a desk writing notes"
  2. "standing at a train platform"
  3. "standing in a bookstore browsing"
  4. "sitting on a couch watching TV"

24.Enter the best set based on the three criteria

The first image is the reference image with the text description:

  1. "A photo of a deer"
The reference image is followed by four image sets (A, B, C, D), each in a row. Each column corresponds to the same text description:
  1. "standing in a forest meadow"
  2. "walking through autumn leaves"
  3. "lying in tall grass"
  4. "sitting in dappled sunlight"
25.Enter the best set based on the three criteria

The first image is the reference image with the text description:

  1. "an elderly man, gray beard, green jacket"
The reference image is followed by four image sets (A, B, C, D), each in a row. Each column corresponds to the same text description:
  1. "walking in the park"
  2. "standing near a bus stop"
  3. "sitting on a porch chair"
  4. "jogging along a river path"
Current Progress,
0 of 25 answered