Potential Pathways into Domestic Heat Decarbonisation Occupations

BE-ST is undertaking research for Skills Development Scotland on potential pathways into domestic heat decarbonisation occupations. This survey will help us understand how people currently enter retrofit occupations, the barriers to workforce growth, and whether more flexible or additional pathways could support people to develop the competence needed to work in the sector.

We are seeking views from people with experience or knowledge of retrofit, training, workforce development or delivery.

The survey covers current pathways, competence requirements, barriers to entry, potential alternative pathways, and the opportunities and risks associated with these approaches.

The research is not intended to advocate for a particular training model or pathway. We are interested in gathering a range of evidence and perspectives to inform an independent assessment of potential options.

The survey should take approximately 10 minutes to complete.
1.Which retrofit occupation(s) or area(s) of work does your response relate to?
Please list the occupation(s) or area(s) in which you have experience or with which you are familiar. You may list more than one. If your answers differ by occupation, please make this clear where relevant.
(Required.)
A. Existing pathways into retrofit
2.How clear and accessible are the current pathways into the retrofit occupation(s) or area(s) you identified?
Very clear
Clear
Neither clear or unclear
Unclear
Very unclear
Don't know
3.How effectively do existing qualifications, apprenticeships and training routes support someone with no relevant experience to become competent in the retrofit occupation(s) you identified?
Very ineffectively
Ineffectively
Neither effectively nor ineffectively
Effectively
Very effectively
Don’t know
4.Are there retrofit or retrofit-adjacent occupations (e.g. manufacturers, suppliers, potentially installers) where you believe there is currently no clear or appropriate pathway for someone with no relevant experience to enter the occupation?
5.If yes, please identify the occupation(s) and describe what is missing from the current pathway.
6.Which elements of existing pathways into the retrofit occupation(s) you identified could be more focused on retrofit, and what changes would be needed?
B. Competence and practical experience
7.How do you currently determine whether someone is competent in the retrofit occupation(s) you identified and ready to work without supervision? Please consider the skills, knowledge, behaviours, practical experience, assessment results and any other evidence you would expect to see.
8.How important is practical experience of retrofit activities alongside formal training when developing competence in the occupation(s) you have identified?
Not important
Slightly important
Moderately important
Very important
Essential
Don’t know
9.What should someone be able to demonstrate before being considered competent to work without supervision in the retrofit occupation(s) you identified?
C. Barriers to bringing new entrants into retrofit employer barriers
10.What are the main barriers that prevent employers from recruiting and training people with no relevant experience in construction, building services or retrofit?
D. Individual barriers
11.What would help employers recruit people with no relevant experience and support them to become competent retrofit workers?
Not significant
Slightly significant
Moderately significant
Very significant
Extremely significant
Don’t know
Lack of awareness of retrofit career opportunities
Lack of suitable entry-level jobs
Lack of clear pathways into retrofit
Cost of training
Loss of earnings while training
Availability of training
Geographic accessibility of training
Entry or qualification requirements
Lack of opportunities to gain practical experience
Pay and employment conditions
Uncertainty about long-term employment opportunities
D. Alternative pathways to competence
12.Could more flexible or additional pathways help new entrants become competent in retrofit occupations, alongside existing routes, provided that appropriate assessment and quality-assurance arrangements are in place?
13.Which alternative or additional approaches could help new entrants become competent in retrofit occupations?
14.What safeguards would be needed to ensure that alternative or accelerated pathways produce people who are competent to work without supervision?
E. Existing workers transitioning into retrofit
15.For people already working in construction or building services, what are the main barriers to moving into retrofit occupations?
16.Could existing occupation or training pathways be broadened or adapted to better incorporate the skills, knowledge and behaviours needed for retrofit?
F. Potential source occupations and sectors
17.Which existing occupations or sectors could be sources of new entrants or career changers for the retrofit occupation(s) you identified?
18.For each occupation or sector you identified, how closely does its existing skill set match the competence required for the relevant retrofit occupation?
Very far from the required competence
Somewhat far from the required competence
Neither close nor far
Somewhat close to the required competence
Very close to the required competence
Don’t know
19.What additional skills, knowledge, experience or training would someone from these occupations or sectors need to become competent in the retrofit occupation(s)?
G. Opportunities, risks and minimum requirements
20.What are the greatest opportunities associated with creating more flexible and diverse pathways into retrofit?
21.What are the greatest risks associated with creating more flexible, diverse or accelerated pathways into retrofit?
22.What minimum requirements for competence, assessment and quality assurance should apply, regardless of the pathway taken into a retrofit occupation?
23.Is there anything else that should be considered when developing new or alternative pathways into the retrofit workforce?
Data Protection

BE-ST will use and process information provided in accordance with the requirements of applicable data protection and privacy legislation in force in the UK. The purpose of this survey is to gather insight to inform research, policy development and industry activity within the built environment and construction sector. Survey responses may be analysed and shared in aggregated and anonymised form with partner organisations, including Scottish Government, Construction Industry Collective Voice (CICV), Optimat, and Scottish Enterprise.

The information you provide us with may be held on files, both paper and electronic. Information obtained will be used solely for the internal purpose of this research project. For further information regarding the way in which BE-ST may use any personal data you supply, please refer to our Privacy Notice.
24.I confirm that I have read and understood how my data will be used and consent to BE-ST processing my personal data for the purposes described above.(Required.)