Before starting this survey, please make sure you have reviewed the candidate materials for all applications and staff assessment of applicants' expertise (applicable only for 2017 candidates), available at: https://community.icann.org/x/rg_8BQ

Question Title

* 1. Name of Evaluator:

Question Title

* 2. Date Evaluation Conducted:

Date

Question Title

* 3. Based on the candidate's materials or your own personal experience, do you think that the candidate has sufficient knowledge of & experience with the GNSO Community to be able to represent the GNSO as a GNSO endorsed candidate?

  Yes No / Don't know
Wolfgang Kleinwaechter - 2017 primary candidate
Michael Karanicolas - 2017 additional candidate
Adetola Sogbesan - 2017 additional candidate
Erica Varlese - 2017 additional candidate - endorsed by RySG in 2018
Shirley Lin - 2017 applicant, not selected
Julien Chaisse - 2017 applicant, not selected
Jacques Blanc - 2018 endorsed applicant
Alperen Eken - 2018 applicant
Patrick Kane - 2018 endorsed applicant
Roli Mahajan - 2018 applicant
Osvaldo Novoa - 2018 endorsed applicant
Brian Scarpelli - 2018 applicant

Question Title

* 4. Does the candidate's application clearly demonstrate that the candidate has the necessary skills, expertise, and attributes to do the work?

Desired Skills and Experience
  • Performance assessment and audits
  • Good governance and board performance
  • Performance measurement
  • Process improvement
  • Knowledge of recognized frameworks for organizational excellence
  • Principles of accountability applicable to organizations broadly similar to ICANN
  • Expertise with Cross Community Working Group (CCWG) Work Stream 1 (WS1) and Work Stream 2 (WS2) highly desired
Desired Attributes
  • Commitment and time to participate
  • Multistakeholder community understanding
  • Team spirit, adaptability, consensus-seeking attitude
  • Willingness to learn
  • Readiness to contribute
  • Capacity to reason objectively, putting aside personal opinions or preconceptions
  • Analytical skills
  • Good communication skills using multiple methods and tools

  Yes No / Don't know
Wolfgang Kleinwaechter - 2017 primary candidate
Michael Karanicolas - 2017 additional candidate
Adetola Sogbesan - 2017 additional candidate
Erica Varlese - 2017 additional candidate - endorsed by RySG in 2018
Shirley Lin - 2017 applicant, not selected
Julien Chaisse - 2017 applicant, not selected
Jacques Blanc - 2018 endorsed applicant
Alperen Eken - 2018 applicant
Patrick Kane - 2018 endorsed applicant
Roli Mahajan - 2018 applicant
Osvaldo Novoa - 2018 endorsed applicant
Brian Scarpelli - 2018 applicant

Question Title

* 5. Please rank these candidates in order of preference with regards to how the candidate meets the skills and experience as outlined in the call for volunteers (1 being most preferred candidate, 9 being the least preferred candidate)

Desired Skills and Experience
  • Performance assessment and audits
  • Good governance and board performance
  • Performance measurement
  • Process improvement
  • Knowledge of recognized frameworks for organizational excellence
  • Principles of accountability applicable to organizations broadly similar to ICANN
  • Expertise with Cross Community Working Group (CCWG) Work Stream 1 (WS1) and Work Stream 2 (WS2) highly desired

Question Title

* 6. Please rank these candidates in order of preference with regards to how the candidate meets the desired attributes as outlined in the call for volunteers (1 being most preferred candidate, 9 being the least preferred candidate)

Desired Attributes
  • Commitment and time to participate
  • Multistakeholder community understanding
  • Team spirit, adaptability, consensus-seeking attitude
  • Willingness to learn
  • Readiness to contribute
  • Capacity to reason objectively, putting aside personal opinions or preconceptions
  • Analytical skills
  • Good communication skills using multiple methods and tools

Question Title

* 7. Evaluator's Comments/Observations:

T