Presentation Scoresheet S1 Question Title * 1. Enter your initials. This is for record keeping purposes, and your identity will not be included in the scores that will be sent to this presenter after the meeting. Question Title * 2. Please submit only one response form per presenter. Note that this survey will collect senders’ IP addresses. Acknowledged Question Title * 3. Hypothesis / Statement of Goals (5 points): + Stated clearly + Logical + Appropriate background + Connections to broader relevance (4 points) (3 points): Some problems with statement of hypothesis and justification (2 points) (1 point): + No clear goals + No background + Illogical Question Title * 4. Results and Data Presentation (5 points): + Substantial data + Adequate controls + Clearly / Logically Presented (4 points) (3 points): + Some issues with data presentation + Some issues with results or controls (2 points) (1 point): + Absence of results + serious lack of controls Question Title * 5. Conclusions and Overall Presentation (5 points): + Strong communicator + Conclusions relate to hypothesis and broader context + Answers questions well (4 points) (3 points): + Issues with clarity / communication + Conclusions not matched with hypotheses or wider context (2 points) (1 point): + Absence of conclusions and discussion + No connection to goals or hypothesis + Not understandable Done
