Ponto East and Ponto West - Shopoff questions – May 3, 2017

1. DWELLING DENSITY: The area East of Ponto Road is now zoned R-23 (15 dwelling units per acre minimum to 23 dwelling units per acre maximum), not including State affordable housing density bonus:

·         Shopoff is proposing 137 dwellings on 6.5 net acres (= 21 dwelling units/acre)

·         Potentially with additional dwellings for an affordable housing density bonus
Should Shopoff's proposed density be:

Question Title

* Should Shopoff's proposed density be:

2. HEIGHT OF BUILDINGS: currently proposed on the East side of Ponto Road are:

· 40 feet high (3 story)

· These buildings would be the tallest along the SW Carlsbad coast

· Commercial buildings like hotels are limited to 35 feet tall

· The building heights for the Poinsettia Shores Planned Community [which San Pacifico is majority of the development and the Shopoff and Kam Sang proposals are minor developments] limits building heights to 30-35 feet.

· All San Pacifico residential buildings except Santalina [35 feet tall] are no taller than 30 feet and must have a minimum 3/12 roof pitch

· The Ponto Beachfront Village Vision Plan that provides additional development guidance for the Shopoff proposed development specifically calls this area the “townhomes” area and shows 2-story [under 30 feet] townhomes as the ‘vision’ for the site.
Should the Shopoff proposed 3-story and 40 feet building heights be reduced to 2-story and/or no taller than 30-35 feet maximum to be consistent with the vision and more compatible with the Poinsettia Shores and San Pacifico community?

Question Title

* Should the Shopoff proposed 3-story and 40 feet building heights be reduced to 2-story and/or no taller than 30-35 feet maximum to be consistent with the vision and more compatible with the Poinsettia Shores and San Pacifico community?

3. BUILDING INTENSITY: The Shopoff proposed stacked flat residential buildings have underground parking to allow more land use intensity and building mass. The proposed buildings run in a fairly contiguous cluster west of the railroad right-of-way from Avenida Encinas north to Ponto Storage.

· Shopoff’s proposed residential square footage [not including any balconies, private recreation or ancillary buildings] is 247,100 square feet total in 3 stories at 40 feet high (82,000 sq ft per story).

· For reference the Carlsbad Costco building is about 115,500 square feet in 1 story at 35 feet high. So Shopoff’s proposed residential building footprint is approximately 72% of the Carlsbad Costco, though it would be 5 feet higher than Costco.
A. Is Shopoff’s proposed building intensity compatible with San Pacifico and the Poinsettia Shores Community and appropriate?

Question Title

* A. Is Shopoff’s proposed building intensity compatible with San Pacifico and the Poinsettia Shores Community and appropriate?

B. Should Shopoff place story poles on-site to show and photo document the proposed building mass?

Question Title

* B. Should Shopoff place story poles on-site to show and photo document the proposed building mass?

4. THE BEACHFRONT VILLAGE COMMERCIAL SITE: west of Ponto Drive proposes some design issues that may be of concern:

· A driveway entrance/exit along Avenida Encinas between Ponto Road and Carlsbad Blvd may make pedestrian/bike travel to the beach less safe.

· The site is proposed to filled with soil to lift the ground level at Coast Highway 9 feet higher and buildings put upon this higher ‘building pad’

· The proposed building designs and material qualities may be of concern

· A proposed grassy park-like ‘common area’ that can be used by customers and community may connect with the City’s land and planned trail under Coast Highway [Carlsbad Boulevard]
A. Should a driveway if needed be on Avenida Encinas, Coast Highway or Ponto Road?

Question Title

* A. Should a driveway if needed be on Avenida Encinas, Coast Highway or Ponto Road?

B. Should Shopoff be allowed to fill the site to 9 feet??

Question Title

* B. Should Shopoff be allowed to fill the site to 9 feet??

C. Are the proposed building design and qualities sufficient to be the commercial and community heart of the Ponto Beachfront Village?

Question Title

* C. Are the proposed building design and qualities sufficient to be the commercial and community heart of the Ponto Beachfront Village?

D. Is the proposed ‘common area’ desirable?

Question Title

* D. Is the proposed ‘common area’ desirable?

E. If so, do you prefer:

Question Title

* E. If so, do you prefer:

5. THE POINSETTIA SHORES MASTER PLAN and Local Coastal Program require prior to any land use change on the Shopoff site [approximately 10 net acres] a documented evaluation of making the East of Ponto Drive site recreation facilities (i.e. “public park”), or lower cost beach visitor accommodations.

· Since 2012 the San Pacifico, Ponto and entire Southwest quadrant of Carlsbad have been in a Park standard deficient [not meeting the City’s minimum 3 acres of Park per 1,000 population City Growth Management Program Standard].

· In 2015 our Southwest quadrant needed 6.6 acres of new City Park to comply with Growth Management Standards.
Should the Shopoff East site [or portion of the site] be: (select one or more, give examples)

Question Title

* Should the Shopoff East site [or portion of the site] be: (select one or more, give examples)

6. PARKING: There is not a lot of excess or extra parking in the current Shopoff proposal and this will not be a “Gated” community. Concerns have been raised regarding vacation rental by owner (VRBO) and beach access parking in this new development.

· Parking in this area is already a problem on weekends and during the summer

· Additional residential units and VRBO may make this problem worse
A. Should Shopoff modify their development plans to accommodate more parking for potential VRBO parking in their development?

Question Title

* A. Should Shopoff modify their development plans to accommodate more parking for potential VRBO parking in their development?

B. Have you experienced problems with VRBO and parking in your neighborhood?

Question Title

* B. Have you experienced problems with VRBO and parking in your neighborhood?

C. What parking solutions would you propose?

Question Title

* C. What parking solutions would you propose?

T